Sunday, May 19, 2019

Would you Rather: Spark Interest or Keep your Students Quiet?

 Sparking students' interest in the math classroom means you are letting students "own" learning.  The element of surprise is wrapped around the problem you pose to your students and productive struggle occurs when you step outside of the equation and no longer serve as the variable to be isolated in the classroom.  Teachers guide student learning with open-ended questions and tools to support discovery.  

By Guest Blogger: Heather Szabo
In my classroom I commonly use “Would you Rather?” questions as a warm-up or an appetizer. Students usually choose an option and are asked to be able to support their argument with mathematical reasoning.
Question: "Would you rather have your weight in pennies or your height in quarters?"
This particularly days question sparked a powerful debate so we decided to explore the problem deeper. Students identified that in order to prove which they would rather, they would need to know the weight of themselves and of a single penny as well as the height of a quarter and the height of themselves. I collected the materials and student table teams explored. In the moment I did not know that a simple question would turn into our whole unit of study on linear equations and writing/solving systems of equations. This lesson driven by students was much better than the storybook problems I have used in the past.
Set Up: Each student in the grouped followed the same protocol and we collected data as a whole class to prove which would equate to a larger value, the weight of a student in pennies or the height of a student in quarters.

Students first weighed themselves using a digital scale in pounds. Students then used a kitchen scale to weigh pennies. Each group weighed a different number of pennies. The mean penny measurement was 10 pennies with a measurement in grams. Students then used conversion facts to calculate the number of pennies that would be equal to the weight of each student.

Once students had a total number of pennies they calculated the value in dollars.
Students used 10 pennies and divided to find a unit rate. Students noticed that they were getting different measurements for weight of the pennies based on the image on the penny. We researched this and found that pennies minted after 1982 have two different weights.

Following the penny/weight measurement students did a height/quarter measurement. Students first measure their height in inches using a measuring tape. Students the converted that measurement to meters. Students measured the height of a stack of 10 quarters and recorded the measurement in mm. Students then used conversion facts to calculate the number of quarters that would be equal in height to each student. Once students had a total number of quarters they calculated the total value in dollars.

After collecting all of the data students realized that for some students choosing pennies would be most profitable and for others choosing quarters would be most profitable depending on their height and weight ratio. We then extended this activity to figure out at what height and weight you would rather choose pennies or quarters. We used this example to cover topics of linear equations and systems of equations.
When finished students asked questions like: What if we chose dimes instead of pennies? Since dimes are smaller but have more value students were interested to see if the outcome would be the same. So we embarked on the same journey led solely from student questioning and facilitated by the teacher.

Reflection: This appetizer turned entree was rewarding for both the students and myself. It truly embodied the five key aspects of project based learning including: real world connection, academic rigor, student driven, multifaceted assessment and structured collaboration

First the question was real to them. They chose to seek the answer out which was the driving force. Second, the rigor was embedded within the lesson. Once students had their own data, they shared it with the class. We then looked to the class data to make predictions and generalizations. We used this time to create graphs and solve systems of equations which is the next chapter of our current curriculum. I let them ask genuine questions and pursue the answers themselves and that is where it led. Some student groups were more ambitious than others. Many groups struggled with the unit rates and conversions so we took time to discuss proportions via a mini lesson in class. The rest just fell together. In this lesson, I was really able to take on the facilitator role and let the investigation be student driven. This is not to say that the lesson was without struggle but the struggles students faced were productive struggles that they persevered through.
When the students asked if this situation would hold true if we used dimes instead of pennies I responded, “I don’t know! Let’s find out!” Due in part to this the finding out became an adventure for students which caused them to buy in more to the lesson itself. 

Saying yes to student ideas in this instance was easy because students were so inquisitive. They wanted to know more which paved the way for much deeper understanding.  

I wholehearted believe that we as math educators are responsible for creating students that are comfortable enough with numbers to challenge and question the authority of numbers. I want my students more than anything to be well prepared to be consumers in a market that is out to take advantage of the mathematically illiterate.

As stated in the video, “without mathematical literacy career opportunities shrink and students become easy prey for credit card companies, payday lenders, the lottery and anyone really that has a dazzling statistic. Because when we aren't comfortable with math we don’t questions the authority of numbers.” I want my students to question and to seek answers and during this lesson that is exactly what they did! 

Heather Szabo is a 7th Grade Math Teacher. She is learning different approaches to math instruction in the course The Math In Our Lives which focuses on designing instruction based on real-world application. 

Join my Facebook Group Teacher Prep Tech or Making Math Connections for more freebies and best practices in teaching with digital tools! 


  1. Thanks for sharing #wyrmath! If you ever have a prompt that you want added to the site, please feel free to reach out: stevens009 at gmail

  2. These were like some of the best would you rather questions you shared. You should also try my deep would you rather questions as they are best to know someone on personal level.

  3. What a great post! I love how you do the would you rather questions in your classroom! This technique really gives students a chance to participate in their learning and have a choice as to what they want to do. It also makes them exercise their critical thinking skills and get in-depth with the problem at hand. Children are naturally inquisitive and I would definitely rather spark interest in my classroom over making my students keep quiet. As educators it is our job to spark this creativity and interest in various subjects. Overall, great blog post! It really got me thinking as to how I could incorporate these aspects into my own classroom.

  4. The author has discussed a very resourceful topic in times of the pandemic. We, as a nation, cannot keep our children out of schools forever. Hence a plan needs to be implemented where children can safely go to school without getting mass infected. However, it is not recommended for parents or children to go physically to the shops for book supplies. Hence there is a need for an online book shop such as KitaabNow.

  5. Hi, It's a nice content. I am just searching on interne, and found your blog. Keep sharing the good content. We are bird lover, and help the people about the different birds. You can install the birdfeederist app to get instant access to different bird related resources.

  6. Nice to spend some quality time on your blog. Keep sharing the good content. It’s a nice content to engage the audience. If you are a bird lover, you can spend some quality time by reading about hummingbird.

  7. Would you rather questions are always very interesting to ask. It's a nice activity to keep the kids engaged. Here you will found some interesting information about the hummingbirds.

  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

  9. I appreciate that you’re going out of the way to teach students, especially the most difficult subject which is maths. My parents wanted me to choose maths as my subject but I was not good at it so I selected literature. Lately; I’ve been looking for some English Literature dissertation ideas and I landed on your post; maybe I’ll find something from here.